STATE OF THE MARKET

Automotive Repair Shop Owners and DIFM Customers

The needs of DIFM (“do it for me”) customers are growing as vehicles become more advanced and complex. What marketing strategies and services offered are working the best for shop owners, and what else do DIFM customers want from their repair shops?

In May of 2025, in partnership with AutoZone, Endeavor Business Intelligence surveyed 300 automobile repair shop owners and 1,000 DIFM customers who have had their vehicle repaired by an automotive repair shop in the last 12 months, providing incredibly valuable insight into the customer experience that all shop owners can use to improve their operations.

The result? A fascinating deep dive into how DIFM customers respond to specific marketing strategies, the services they look for in a shop, and their overall satisfaction, along with a glimpse of shop owners’ current marketing plans and their effectiveness.

Customers consider several factors when choosing a shop, and strong customer service, speed, low cost, and expertise drive loyalty.

DIFM customers are more likely to return to businesses they trust, especially for high-cost services like automotive repair. We asked customers which factors would most influence their decision in choosing a shop, and here’s what they said:

Expertise

0%
DIFM customers want to know that their vehicle is repaired to the highest standards possible — 86% of survey respondents reported that shop expertise was very or extremely important to them when deciding where to have their vehicle serviced. Shops who tout their experienced technicians can provide that reassurance.

Speed

0%
Same-day service is a major selling point for DIFM customers choosing a repair shop, with 79% saying it makes them more likely or much more likely to visit. However, only 31% of shops can complete services within a single day, revealing an opportunity for shops to improve customer satisfaction and gain a competitive edge.

Cost

0%
Naturally, customers will always be conscious of pricing, especially when a vehicle needs more than a routine service or repair. When asked what factors they considered important when choosing an auto repair shop, 52% of customers ranked repair cost as their top priority.

Service

0%
47% of DIFM customers cited customer service as extremely important, ranking it significantly higher than factors such as speed of service or convenient hours of operation. This suggests that DIFM customers are willing to wait longer or even work around their schedule to ensure they receive top-quality automotive service.

Positive experiences drive repeat visits, but customers are still cost-sensitive.

Data shows most customers currently enjoy the experience they receive from their repair shop. Almost all customers who took the survey reported having a positive experience with their current repair shop, with 42% of DIFM customers describing themselves as “very satisfied” and 45% as “extremely satisfied.” Forty-one percent of DIFM customers reported choosing a shop for non-routine repairs because they have already used that shop before. Shop owners are relying on that loyalty as much as they can — 73% of shop owners consider their primary customers to be repeat or loyal customers. This aligns with shop owners’ trust in word-of-mouth marketing and the fact that loyal, repeat customers are a primary source of income.
However, shop owners should pay attention to the fact that many DIFM customers are open to servicing their vehicles at different shops within a specified period. In fact, 42% of DIFM customers used two different shops within the last two years, while 20% used three to four different shops, and more than 60% of DIFM customers were willing to try a competitor out within two years of each other. The top reason for choosing one shop over another was seeking the lowest price quote (49% of respondents), a significant factor when you consider that 84% of DIFM customers consider getting a second quote for vehicle repairs. Shop owners should be aware that many customers visit multiple repair shops in a short period, making price a competitive factor.

Most shops can improve their methods to market to potential customers, showing opportunities for growth.

Shop owners who rely on a limited set of marketing strategies may overlook valuable marketing opportunities. So, how can shops effectively reach customers?

Social Media Platforms
Advertising
Loyalty Programs
Word-of-Mouth

Social Media Platforms

Among all social media platforms, Facebook, YouTube, and Instagram emerged as the most popular among DIFM customers, with 56% of respondents using Facebook daily, 49% watching YouTube videos daily, and 31% logging in to Instagram at least once each day. However, shop owners are not reaching these markets as effectively as they could, with only 38% of respondents currently using social media as an advertising platform, while a marginal 12% of owners were leveraging video marketing for advertising purposes.

Platforms Used Daily

  • Facebook 56% 56%
  • YouTube 49% 49%
  • Instagram 31% 31%

Advertising

DIFM customers are looking for promotional opportunities that help them save money, with 72% responding that special offers for routine services would make them more or much more likely to visit a repair shop. Unfortunately, only 15% of shops sent out seasonal specials via email, and only 9% used mailing campaigns, signifying that there aren’t many promotional discounts being offered.

0%

Special offers encourage return visits

Loyalty Programs

The majority of DIFM customers — 53% — said they would be more or much more likely to visit a shop that rewards customer loyalty. Once again, shop owners did not see the same value, with no shop owners ranking loyalty programs as a top choice for effective methods to attract customers. Only 14% of shops reported having a loyalty program. Shop owners are missing opportunities to meet customer desires by not exploring innovative marketing approaches within the automotive industry.

0%
Shops that have a customer loyalty program

Word-of-Mouth

Shop owners overwhelmingly rely on word-of-mouth marketing, with 79% of those surveyed considering it the most effective strategy for attracting new customers and maintaining existing relationships with customers. In fact, of all the shops surveyed, 88% reported using word-of-mouth marketing to attract new customers. Shop owners are currently relying on informal marketing methods, which are effective in some aspects, but can miss the overall target.

  • Shop owners consider word-of-mouth as a best-practice 79% 79%
  • Shops use word-of-mouth for new business 88% 88%

There’s an interesting disconnect in shop owner sentiment and shop growth, showing a potential to invest in different strategies to increase business.

While 66% of shop owners said they are very or extremely satisfied with their conversion rate of service quotes to sales, 30% reported slow growth over the past year, while 48% reported moderate growth. As the market remains competitive, shop owners should consider the following to maximize their marketing strategy to current and prospective customers:

Loyalty Programs

Loyalty Programs

Reward your best or repeat customers with incentives to keep them coming back for maintenance or repairs.

Seasonal Offers

Seasonal Offers

While some coupon-focused folks might take advantage of this, it’s a low-risk way to expand a client base.

Create Videos

Create Videos

Short clips on Facebook, Instagram, or YouTube don’t have to be fancy and are a great way to introduce your team, explain services, or share repair tips.

Google Business Profiles

Google Business Profiles

If you haven't claimed your shop, do so, and then update hours, photos, and customer reviews to improve online visibility.

Ask for Reviews

Ask for Reviews

Encourage satisfied customers to post online feedback after each visit to build trust with new prospects.

Expand Social Media

Expand Social Media

Post regularly on Facebook and Instagram and mix up messaging to build community and create a trusting, relatable environment.

Invest in Training + Tech

Invest in Training + Tech

Keep your shop competitive by staying current with EV, ADAS, and diagnostic systems.

Streamline Scheduling

Streamline Scheduling

With many platforms available, find an online booking service that works for you. Bonus if it includes texting features or builds same-day service options.

Additional Resources

Full Look at Shop Marketing

In the full report to this overview, get a clear look at how repair-shop owners and DIFM customers experience today’s service environment. Explore the factors shaping customer loyalty, communication, purchasing behavior, and operational challenges — offering a data-driven view of where expectations meet and where opportunities exist to close the gap.

Recruiting and Retaining Gen Z Technicians

Discover how shop owners and Gen Z technicians view the changing landscape of automotive repair, with insights into training, compensation, recruitment, technology use, and day-to-day job expectations. This resource highlights where perspectives align, where they differ, and what it means for the future of the industry.

Multiple Resources for Your Shop

Access a growing collection of technical insights, business guidance, and product-driven resources built for professional technicians and shop leaders. From repair-procedure support to strategies for improving workflow and profitability, this library delivers practical tools to help your shop perform at its best.

For more information about AutoZone

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.